Check NG0s with political leanings’
The new NGOs in Penang have broken from the traditional mould and are seen as lackeys of political parties.
GEORGE TOWN: The chances are that if you throw a stone in Penang you are most likely to hit an NGO. In the last five years, the island has seen a mushrooming of non-governmental organisations.
The traditional NGOs champion causes like the disabled, environment and other social ills. But the new ones have dubious leaders and most of them are shadows of political parties.
One man who is very concerned with the unwanted rise of NGOs is Penang Malay Congress president Rahmad Isahak.
He wants the Registrar of Societies (ROS) to probe the rise of several NGOs here since 2008.
Rahmad said many of the new NGOs seem to be involved in the political and socio-economic issues in the state.
He said that the formation of new NGOs is healthy as it shows an acceptance of civil society and democracy here.
But at the same time, the issues and individuals behind such groups are seen as dubious at best, Rahmad claimed in an interview.
The new NGOs seemed to be championing political issues rather than the conventional norms such as the rights of the disabled or protecting the environment.
They seem to have exploited the loopholes in the ROS guidelines to form and name organisations, without any clear reference to how many members they have, submission of accounts and other criteria imposed by our watchdog of societies.
Dubious names
Therefore, the congress is encouraging ROS to investigate such organisations to ascertain if they are sincere and genuine, he added.
He said dubious organisational names have appeared in media reports together with individuals, who were previously unheard of in the local NGO scene here.
The new NGOs have organised protests – some turning violent, lodging police reports for all kinds of issues and in some instances, have tried to intimidate politicians such as the recent vandalism of a vehicle carrying PKR vice-president Tian Chua in Penang, Rahmad said.
“This is an undesirable attitude for those claiming to be NGOs. Such groups form the focus of a civil society where dialogues and forums are seen as the best platform to champion their struggle or objectives.”
Since Independence, Penang has been the home to an active collection of NGOs and civil societies with the Consumers Association of Penang (CAP) as the leading light.
In the last decade, some NGOs in Penang have gone on to form the Penang Forum platform which meets on certain occasions to discuss issues dear to them.
Rahmad said the congress is appreciative of the contributions made by the likes of CAP and other NGOs such as the environmental group, SAM, but he is distrustful of the newer NGOs which seemed to be more interested in politics.
Confusing the people
These NGOs are aggressive and champion sensitive issues such as race and religion, he said.
They are confusing the people here, as on the one hand, they are NGOs, which are supposed to be impartial at best, but then they are constantly attacking Pakatan Rakyat leaders such as Anwar Ibrahim and Lim Guan Eng, Rahmad said.
Admitting that the congress is also new here, he said that it was formed based on the guidelines under ROS four years ago and it advocates impartiality.
“We criticised without fear or favour, either Barisan Nasional or Pakatan as one can determine by our media statements and reports.”
Rahmad said while the congress was formed to protect the interests of Malays in Penang, particularly on the island, they feel that other NGOs were being unfair to Lim because he has only been the Penang chief minister for one term.
Rightly, Lim has flaws and may have made mistakes, but the violent manner of how the NGOs reacted to it, is being unfair to him, he said.
The constant demonstrations and personal attacks against him should stop.
He said Lim was already made aware of the need to pay attention to the plight of the Malays, who are lagging behind others under the socio-economic scope here.
Now, the onus is for him to prove that he can deliver for the Malays and he must try harder, Rahmad said.
Tiada ulasan:
Catat Ulasan